Compression Lock Patent Expires this Month

Interesting.

 

It's a very hand friendly lock design, it will be nice to see it more widespread but it will always be a Spyderco thing to me.

 

When Spyderco decided to make more comp locks the past few years I've noticed that getting the geometry right is trickier than it seemed. The PM2 worked so well that I, like many others, assumed you could throw a comp lock on darn near any knife. Well, it looks like it's not so simple. The Tropen, Sliveraxe, Kapara, Mantra 3, and even the Shaman had to make what I'd consider compromises to get the lock in there.

Tropen - you gon die
Sliveraxe - flipper hits your finger before the blade seats
Kapara - risky one handed close unless you have very slender digits
Mantra 3 - the funky recurve added to avoid a Tropen fate
Shaman - same as Sliveraxe, but it's the choil nub that gets ya.

I'm curious to see how other designers are able to work around this. I like the Smock approach so far.

 

Open season then. May the best one succeed. Or rather the best implementations

 

If we see the implementation as widely as we are seeing it for the loss of patent for the axis lock its going to be a great thing. Some of the issues with the compression lock in the Shaman as kyle pointed out above is the typical spyderco insistence on using a choil with a guard. I can think of some designs already that sport an unguarded finger choil that would be fantastic as a compression lock so long as the rest of the geometries are worked out. Looking forward to seeing some companies try their hand at models sporting this kind of lock.

 

I don't have a Tropen or a Mantra 3, why does the Tropen kill you lol?

 

With respect, I don't care for the compression lock. I'd be happier with a liner lock. That's just me personally! The compression lock on my Paramilitary 2 feels ackward to me, and cramped. My fingers have to tightly grasp the sides of the knife if I'm to close it one handed.

It's hard to explain well. But for me, the comp lock is very ackward for my big hands. I thought I would get used to it, but I never did.

I still adore my PM2 though!

Anyway, I have a gut feeling I'm not the only one. I would take a stab in the dark here and say that it won't take off like the axis lock did for other brands.

 

The Comp lock is my favorite locking mechanism so the more the merrier! There are a lot of frame and liner locks out the I would buy if they had a Comp lock instead.

 

Almost any decent lock would be welcome to displace the vast oversupply of these .

 

You're not alone, it's my least favorite locking mechanism.

 

Live edge to the finger that's disengaging the lock.

It's actually my favorite model of the ones mentioned and doesn't bother me personally, but there probably shouldn't be live edge where your finger goes. Watch any review of it and they'll make mention.

 

Basically the blade is exposed. The issue with models like the Shaman that people notice is that that finger choil guard is coming back and hitting the finger that you are using to pinch the compression lock. For the Tropen, there is no guard there to hit you, but this time it is just part of the blade. This has two problems. One, your finger that you are pinching the lock with can be easily cut if you are trying to flick the blade shut instead of using two hands. Two, it leaves a portion of the blade exposed in the compression lock cut out on the spine area. Unfortunately, that is also the area most likely to come in contact with your hand when you are reaching past the blade for something else in your pocket if you are carrying it tip up (which is how the clip is mounted from the factory).

 

That seems like something that should've never made it past QC

 

I actually like a frame lock myself. I do like the simple button lock and the old R.E.K.A.T. Rolling Lock as well. I still have an old Pioneer model.

I have had a couple of Spyderco Compression locks; a Lil’ Native that I sold and a Salsa that I still have. Not a bad lock just awkward for me to use.

 

I think the compression lock is likely more difficult to implement properly than the axis lock, so I don't know that we'll see quite so many versions hit the market right away. That said, I certainly wouldn't object to more compression lock knives, as I'm very fond of the mechanism.

 

It will be interesting to see other manufacturers takes on the design. I know the compression lock is a big reason I have so many Spydercos.

 

Yes, there's a small part of the blade on the Tropen that's exposed in the compression lock slot but it is NOT as serious a risk as you make out.

Personally, I've never gotten cut closing/holding/manipulating my Tropen (which I have carried daily on occasion) and I've also not had any such problem w/the Ikuchi that is also criticized for a similar reason.

It's all "much ado about nothing" IMO.

Frankly, there's always a risk of getting cut w/any knife regardless of how it is designed and, if you get cut by one, I would attribute that to USER ERROR, not to any design failure provided that the knife will not cut you if held/used in a "normal" matter.

So, if you are getting cut holding/using a Tropen (or the Ikuchi), I'd question how you are holding/using it.

 

why does everyone whine about the shaman bumping their finger? doesn't bother me. if it was a flaw then it wouldn't of been produced with the choil. sure all the whiners know more about knife design than sal does. pocket clip....serrations....now everybody gets comp locks...courtesy of spyderco. but oh the humanity if a knife bumps your poor delicate finger